Baire Category Theorem

[[concept]]
Baire Category Theorem

Let M be a {as||complete} metric space and let {Cn}n be a {as||collection of closed subsets} of M such that $$M = \bigcup_{n \in N}C_{n}$$Then {ha||at least one} of the Cn {ha||contain an open ball}
{ha||$$B(x,r) = { y \in M : d(x,y) <r }$$}
ie, {ha||at least one} Cn has {ha||an interior point}.

Note

A set that does not contain an interior point is called nowhere dense. Sometimes when we apply this theorem, we do not need Cn to be closed. Then the result is that their closures must contain and open ball. ie, we cannot have all Cn be all nowhere dense.

Note

We can use this theorem to prove that there exists a continuous function that is nowhere differentiable

Proof (by contradiction)

Suppose BWOC that there is some collection of closed subsets of M such that nCn=M and all Cn are nowhere dense.

Note

we'll show that there is a sequence in M that does not converge

Since M contains an open ball but C1 does not, we have MC1. Thus there is some p1MC1. Since C1 is closed but MC1 is open, this implies that ϵ1>0 s.t. B(p1,ϵ1)C1=.

Now, B(p1,ϵ13)C2 means there exists some p2MC2. And since C2 is closed, there exists 0<ϵ2<ϵ13 such that B(p2,ϵ2)C2=

Now, suppose there we have found k such points. Then for each j=1,,k we have pjCj withϵj such that B(pj,ϵj)Cj=

Since B(pk,ϵk3)Ck+1, there exists some pk+1B(pk,ϵk3) such that pk+1Ck+1

Then there exists ϵk+1<ϵk3 such that B(pk+1,ϵk+1)Ck+1=

Thus, by indiction, we have found a sequence of points {pk}kM and ϵk(0,ϵ1) such that for all k,

  1. pjB(pj1,ϵj13)
  2. B(pj,ϵj)Cj=

This sequence {pk}k is Cauchy because for all k,N, we have

d(pk+1,pk+)d(pk,pk+1)+d(pk+1,pk+2)++d(pk+1,pk+)<ϵk3+ϵk+13++ϵk+13<ϵ13k+ϵ13k+1++ϵ13k+<ϵ1n=k13k=ϵ13k(1113)=ϵ123k+1

Since M is complete, there exists some pM such that pkp as k.

Now, for all kN, we have

d(pk+1,pk++1)<ϵk+1[13+132++13]<ϵk+1n=13n=ϵk+12limd(pk+1,pl++1)=d(pk+1,p)ϵk+12<ϵk6

So as , we have

d(pk+1,p)d(pk,p)d(pk,pk+1)+d(pk+1,p)13ϵ+16ϵk<ϵk

ie, pB(pk,ϵk)=Bk for all k. And each of these balls has BkCk=. Thus p is not in any of the Ck ie pkCk=M

References

#flashcards/math/functional

Mentions

Mentions

Created 2025-06-05 Last Modified 2025-06-05